Wooster Street
At the age of 15, Jim began his journey at New Haven, Connecticut’s most renowned pizzeria as a dishwasher. Through dedication and hard work, he learned every position in the restaurant, eventually earning the prestigious title of Pizza Man. Jim was trained by “old school” pros in the “old school” ways to make Apizza. Fantini’s Apizza is not a product churned out by machines; it’s about creating a superior product and crafting memorable experiences for those who enjoy it.
The Dream
In mid-2019, reflecting on the experiences and knowledge gained from working in various restaurants during high school and college, the decision was made to revisit the culinary field. The search for a suitable location began, aiming for something small to bring Jim’s vision to life. After evaluating numerous spots, a nondescript shopping center on Federal Highway in Stuart was discovered, and became the home of Fantini’s New Haven Style Apizza.
The Food
In 2022, Jim put Stuart on the map with his renowned New Haven Style Apizza. Highly acclaimed by notable pizza reviewers Dave Portnoy of Barstool Sports and Frank Gallo of YouTube, the restaurant quickly garnered attention nationwide. Enthusiastic diners from across the U.S. began inquiring about how to visit Stuart and make reservations.
With a background of working in prestigious restaurants in and around New Haven, CT, he brought his culinary expertise, including the finest entrées he mastered, to the Treasure Coast. He describes his cuisine as “Italian soul food,” which has been warmly received by guests. It’s common for first-time visitors to return multiple days in a row, enticed by the delightful aromas of dishes like Bucatini Carbonara and Chicken Shrimp Fantini.
The Restaurant
Meticulously clean and tastefully designed, the restaurant offers a pleasant ambiance with smooth background music. The staff, known for their vibrant personalities, complete the unique vibe of this exceptional dining establishment. We hope to have successfully recreated the 1980s Wooster Street Style experience.
Guests are encouraged to bring family and friends, start a tradition, and share special moments with loved ones…truly embracing the spirit of New Haven.
“Let me cook for YOU tonight!” – Jimmy F.